What homeowners say

Like many on Sanibel Island, I lost my roof to Hurricane Ian. My Homewatch guy recommended Fair & Square. First, they did a heroic job of installing a tarp on the missing portion of our roof before the causeway was repaired. That meant bringing men and material over on a small boat. Then, as soon as my insurance adjuster gave the green light for a roof replacement, they completed the work on time and for a reasonable cost. … Kevin, Rusty, and their crew truly lived up to their company's name. Can't recommend them highly enough.

From the very beginning Shawn and Rusty were extremely attentive to my needs. They showed up when they said they were going to and their crew worked meticulously throughout the duration of the project. His price was fair and the job was done to perfection. The county inspector commented to me that the job was flawless. I highly recommend Fair and Square Roofing!!!

Fair and Square Roofing more than exceeded my expectations. The crew was respectful of my property and went out of their way to make sure they kept the entire job site meticulous. My new tile roof looks amazing. I constantly get compliments now from my neighbors who walk by. … I'm so glad I picked Fair and Square, and I highly recommend this company!!! These are the honest folks!

Fair and Square roofing did a fantastic job! We hired them after our prior contractor left us with only a partial metal roof. … Fair and Square handled all of the permit changes, metal order, and completed our roof faster than we had anticipated. Shawn was easily available to answer questions. Castro and his team worked hard (sometimes 12 hour days) to complete our roof. They came when they said they would and delivered. Highly recommend!

F & S re-roofed our two condo buildings on Sanibel Island (June, 2023) with metal panels after Hurricane Ian damaged the previously-tiled roofs. Rusty and Mike efficiently and effectively shepherded their crews during a particularly difficult time (from multiple aspects - permitting, manpower, weather and supply availability constraints). … it earned those ratings and reinforced that reputation on our job too.

I had a mysterious leak which 2 other roofers had failed to find and fix. Ramon and his great crew did water tests to determine where the intrusion was occurring, and promptly returned to make the repairs. While doing so, they noticed some dried out caulking that they repaired. The job was done very neatly, with no mess left. I will certainly call Fair and Square when I need any more roofing repairs.

I hired Fair and Square Roofing to repair a roof leak. This Company is extremely service oriented. The Saleman, Kevin answered my service call promptly and was able to diagnose the problem … They did a neat and thorough job and roof doesn't leak. I would not hesitate on recommending this company based on their fair price for the repairs and most of all for their honesty and integrity.

Fantastic experience. Kevin Frost was my point of contact - He is experienced, knowledgeable, responsive, and professional. I love my new metal roof and gutters! The workmanship is top notch and the pricing truly is fair and square. I have already recommended this company to friends, family, and to clients of mine. Highly Recommend!

I cannot say enough about this company and the job they did. I signed a contract of Friday and on Monday a truck was dropping off materials. The workforce protected my property and cleaned up each day … Fair and Square completed my job start to finish in under two weeks. I would highly recommend Fair and Square to anyone that needs a roof.

Following Hurricane Ian (2022), just getting a roofer to answer the phone or not putting us on an endless waitlist was challenging. Rusty, the owner, not only picked up the phone himself but promptly sent background info and spent phone time to talk through options, pricing and timing. … Pricing was fair and work commenced as soon as the materials arrived. Very happy with the new roof and the customer service. Highly recommended.

The estimator sent, Colton told me they could do the repair when a previous contractor said I needed a new roof. The repair technician they sent - Javier, was extremely thorough and knowledgeable. He did a very professional job. Will definitely use them when it is time to replace my roof.

I had nothing less than a magnificent experience with this company. The owner, Rusty, reached out to me personally and had a very hands-on and transparent approach. … Rusty made sure he communicated every move with me, sent me progress pictures and was very punctual and responsive. He even conducted a free roof inspection before sending me a proposal. The pricing was very fair as well!

At a time when other roofing companies do not call back or even worse when they repeatedly fail to follow through with their commitments, Fair and Square Roofing lived up to their name. Fair and Square not only got our repair work scheduled, but showed up on time, completed the work as quoted and all at a fair price. … Fair and Square Roofing is a company that I will use and recommend again.

Kevin and the team at Fair and Square Roofing are courteous and professional. They were responsive to our questions and quickly and respectfully addressed any concerns we had. Kevin is very laid back and easy to work with. They did a beautiful job on our reroof and the price was reasonable. 5/5 would recommend

Wow! Finally an honest roofer! I called to have possible roof leak evaluated. Rusty was very thorough and reported a very small leak that was repairable. Totally 100% would recommend!

Fantastic company to work with. Salesman was great and the price to replace my flat roof was excellent.

Fair and square did a great job on my roof they applied hurricane techniques to my roof nailing down the roof applying the membrane and gluing down my roof tiles.

We used this company for a complete roof repair after Hurricane Ian. They have a wonderful staff and are pleasant to work with. The roofers did a great job from beginning to end, to clean up. I would recommend this company to anyone.

Of all the quotes we got, Fair and Square roofing was the lowest and most thorough. Jay was constantly trying to make things easier for me through the process and they weren't pushy trying to up sell us on unnecessary material like other companies do. From start to finish the process took about 10 days! … The roofers always cleaned up at the end of the day.

On a recent purchase of a home, we were in need of an roof inspection and repair. … I called Fair and Square Roofing who quickly provided an on site inspection and a Fair quote. Once we closed Fair and Square responded and repaired the roof promptly and courteously. I could not be happier.